What’s Better for Weight Loss: Low-Carb or Low-Fat?

Low-carb vs. low-fat diets has been one of the most debated questions in nutrition. Both camps claim their approach is best for weight loss and health. But what does the science actually say when we compare them head-to-head?

What the Research Says

What Are Low-Carb and Low-Fat Diets?

Low-Carb Diets typically limit carbohydrate intake (bread, pasta, rice, sugar) and focus on protein and fat. Examples include ketogenic diets and Atkins-style plans. Low-Fat Diets reduce total fat intake, emphasizing lean proteins, grains, fruits, and vegetables, while cutting back on oils, butter, and fatty meats. Both approaches aim to create a calorie deficit, but they work through different macronutrient restrictions.

Short-Term Studies (6–12 months)

Meta-analyses show that low-carb diets often produce slightly greater weight loss (~1–2 kg advantage) compared to low-fat diets. They also improve HDL (“good” cholesterol) and triglycerides. However, low-carb diets may also increase LDL (“bad” cholesterol) in some people

Long-Term Outcomes (1–2 years)

The advantage of low-carb tends to disappear over time. After a year or more, both diets produce similar weight loss results when calories are matched

The DIETFITS Trial (2018)

A large randomized controlled trial (over 600 adults, one year long) found no significant difference in weight loss between low-fat and low-carb diets. Interestingly, genetic makeup and insulin sensitivity did not predict success on either diet

Health Markers

Both diets can improve blood sugar control and body composition if calories are reduced. The key difference is that low-carb tends to improve triglycerides and HDL more, while low-fat can improve LDL and overall cholesterol levels.

So, Which Diet Is Better?

The truth is, neither diet is universally better. The most important factor for weight loss is calorie adherence, sticking to the diet long enough to maintain a calorie deficit.

Low-Carb diets may work better for those who enjoy higher protein/fat foods and find carbs trigger overeating.

Low-Fat diets may be easier for people who prefer grains, fruits, and lean proteins.

Practical Tips

Pick the diet you can stick to long term, sustainability beats “perfection.”

Focus on whole foods and avoid ultra-processed junk, regardless of carb or fat content.

Monitor blood work: if LDL cholesterol rises too much on low-carb, adjust your fat sources (more unsaturated, less saturated fat).

Use protein as your anchor nutrient: both diets work best with adequate protein intake.

Occaecati simili terafvd que?